OAFC BBS - All Topics: Archive: How on Earth is Swisher not an All-Star?!?
Another HUGE home run today!
Both he and Chavez should be all stars...they're carrying this offense for the team
there is no way an athletics player gets voted in this year or any other in the near future. Sad but true. Our only hope is ONE of them gets in via the manager.
Well the two most likley Chavez and Swisher...aren't gonna get any love support. Chavez isn't gonna be ARod and NO WAY Swisher get voted ahead of the likes of Vlad, Ichiro, Manny, and the NYY OFs.
I'm afraid Swish is gonna have to pay more dues. The east coast media will make sure of that.
Is manager is gonna be Guillen?
sorry i had a brain fart: "is manager is".
Yes the manager is Guillen. Remember as of a couple of years ago the back ups and pitchers are picked by the players and then the manager has I believe five selections for "need" players (i.e. filling any one player team picks). Anyways it's waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too early to think about All-Star picks.
The ballots are already available online!
Swisher needs to be written in, if he going to be an All Star. Similar to Byrnes, which lead him to on the final roster list.
Actually it had nothing to do with it. No one has ever been written on to the All-Star team by the fans. Byrnes ended up on the five player, final spot voting list after the rosters were announced but that was chosen by MLB which the fans then vote on.
This is really early, even if you're in last place of your fantasy league, way too early to give up. I think we'll get a clearer picture in June if Swish is all star worthy. If he hits a 2-3 week bad period you can forget it, if he stays reasonably consistent, get into late June with at least a 290 average and 20 jacks, he will get in.
Swisher with another good game...BB and scored in the 1st and then an RBI double in the 2nd.
Consistency into mid June should do it.
After today's game Swisher's stats ranked in the AL only though not counting the other AL players games today....
Also add in that with his 3 BBs, he's in the top 3 or 4 in that category in the AL.
Again we as fans will have no impact on Swisher making the team. He isn't on the ballot and the back ups are chosen by the players. We only have a chance to vote him in is if he ends up on the last man ballot but a Yankee or Red Sox player always wins that. Also it is again way too early to be talking about the All-Star team. Swisher could go into a month long slump for all we know. Jason Kendall could hit .450 the rest of the first half and end up the A's rep...okay maybe not.
LOL...yc...nice Kendall stab.... he is however appearing in the next WWE Royal Rumble and is the projected winner.
yc- Are you sure about your facts? You state,"no one has ever been written onto the All Star team by the fans". A poster on another board writes," Walt Weiss made the all star team as a write in way back in the day when he was a rook and there have been a few others.......While it is a long shot to do it, you can still make the All Star team as a write in." There seems to be much disagreement on the question as to whether or not Swish Can be added to the All Star team via fan write ins.
Walt Weiss never made it to an All-Star team as a member of the A's. He only made it with the Braves in 1998.
Ok, but that's not the question. Has there ever been a player make an All Star team due to fan write ins? You say no-others disagree. I guess the question could be- Does MLB count write in votes on All Star ballots? I don't know.
Actually that was part of the question as you were stating that someone said that it has happened before and that Weiss was an example which was not true. After some quick research only Rico Carty in 1970 and Steve Garvey in 1974 are the only players to ever make the All-Star team as a starter as a write in candidate. So it has happened but it is extremely rare and given that it last happened 32 years ago I would say that the current voting makes it impossible to do so.
And D) IT IS POSSIBLE that a strong write-in campaign could net Swish a spot on the All Star team. Unlikely, I agree, but possible if MLB counts write-in votes on the ballots as the other poster claims. It is obvious that he was mistaken about Weiss making the All Star team as a rookie and as a result of write-in votes. Thanks for clearing that part up.
Questions? Comments? Corrections? Please contact email@example.com.